NRG5000 Theoretical Foundations of Nursing
Dr. Lisa Capps, Faculty
Ethics Final Paper Instructions and Rubric
Choose a topic of an ethical issue that is of interest to you that is relevant to nurses/nursing practice. Ideally, you will choose a topic in which you do not have great deal of knowledge or pre-conceived ideas. This topic will also be relevant to nursing practice. Journals and articles other than those in the nursing profession may be considered. This assignment is a formally written paper in APA format, 7th edition. A minimum of three professional references is required (from 2016 to 2021). You may use internet sites and articles, but they will not be counted as a professional citation. Only a Word document that can be edited will be accepted.
· The term “ethical dilemma” refers to a situation where choices need to be made, the answers may not be clear, the options are not ideal and there may be active barriers to a reasonable solution.
· The topic is objectively defined and described. As nurses we have a duty to our patients to advocate for them. At the same time, we must keep ourselves out of the situation. This section must address the topic with objectivity and facts.
· Write in the third person until you are to provide your personal professional response.
· At least three professional nursing journal articles should be cited to substantiate the facts that are relevant to the topic.
· The paper introduction should be submitted in APA style (7th edition). Please familiarize yourself with APA and how to cite references.
· The final paper should be 6 ½ to 7 ½ pages (double-spaced 12-pt. Times New Roman font).
Use the following as Level One Headings for your paper:
· Identification and Discussion of the Ethical Dimensions
· Relevance of the Ethical Issue to Nursing
· Analysis of Relevant Ethical Principles, Theories, Laws, and Standards of Practice
· Personal Professional Response to the Issue
Identification and Discussion of Ethical Dimensions
Rubric for the Ethics Final Paper:
|Introduction Theme/Objective||Clearly and effectively communicates an introduction of the theme/objective of the ethics topic||Effectively communicates an introduction of the theme/objective of the ethics topic but questions remain||Does not effectively communicate an introduction of the theme/objective of the ethics topic||Misses point completely in introduction of the theme/objective of the ethics topic||/ 3
|Supporting Details||Each detail supports or tells more about the topic and has follow up sentences which provide additional support||Some of the details support the main idea/topic, but some do not||The details do not support the main idea/topic OR there are not enough details||There are no substantiating support for the main idea/topic||/3
|Relevance: Why is this an ethical dilemma in today’s society?||Very strong appropriate interpretation of data and relevant to the topic||Largely appropriate interpretation of data and relevant to topic||May contain some misinterpretation and/or irrelevant material||Limited interpretation and relevance of topic||/ 3
|Ethical analysis: application and discussion of ethical principles, theories, laws, and standards of nursing practice||Ethical principles, theories, laws, and standards of nursing practice are clearly and effectively defined and applied to the topic||Ethical principles, theories, laws, and standards of nursing practice are defined and applied to the topic, but clarity or thoroughness are lacking||Ethical principles, theories, laws, and standards of nursing practice are superficially mentioned or inadequately applied to the topic||Ethical principles, theories, laws, and standards of nursing practice are incorrectly defined or incorrectly applied to the topic||/3|
|Understanding of Topic as Ethical Dilemma for Nursing||Addresses ethical issues in good detail, if appropriate||Addresses ethical issues adequately, if appropriately
|Does not address ethical issues adequately, if appropriate||Ethical issues not appropriately or clearly addressed, if appropriate||/3
|Personal Professional Response to the Issue
|Clearly and effectively presents one’s personal PROFESSIONAL response to the issue||Presents one’s personal PROFESSIONAL response to the issue, but clarity is lacking||Presents one’s personal response to the issue, but emphasizes non-professional experiences||Fails to make a connection between the writer and the topic presented||/3|
|Conclusion: Reflection of What You Learned
|Good summary, clearly articulated||Summarized and adequately articulated||Incomplete summary/superficially articulated||Not a summary/poorly articulated||/3|
|Clarity and Organization
|Headings utilized, paper clear/concise/organized||Headings not utilized, paper clear/concise/organized||No Headings, paper unclear/ not concise/disorganized||Lack of organization obscures meaning or you have not corrected feedback given in prior assignments||/3|
|Spelling and Grammar||No spelling or grammatical errors.
|Less than 3 spelling or grammatical errors||Less than 7 spelling or grammatical errors.
|More than 7 spelling or grammatical errors, errors obscure meaning, or a failure to correct errors discussed in class or feedback from previous assignments||/ 3
|APA format||No APA 7th edition errors||Less than 3 incidents of APA errors||Less than 7 incidents of APA errors||More than 7 incidents of APA errors or failure to correct errors discussed in class or feedback from previous assignments||/3|
|Correct Length: 6 ½-7 ½ pages of text, PLUS title page and references
|Minimum of 3 professional nursing references, 5 years old or less
|Your point total||Points awarded||Your point total||Points awarded|